home

Arizona to Increase Prosecution of Undocumented at Enormous Cost

Despite a severe budget shortage, Arizona is set to begin prosecuting 40 to 60 "apprehended migrants" a day.

This is a very expensive program that is unlikely to be a deterrent.

Even with only 40 prosecutions a day, expenses will likely add up to millions of dollars a year for housing, transporting, prosecuting and defending those who are charged.

While a higher number of arrests clearly occur daily in the Tucson sector, trying to prosecute many more on a daily basis clearly would overwhelm the system, various federal officials say.

On the impact: [More....]

The impact will range from requiring magistrate judges to be available and finding enough qualified private lawyers to help represent the bulk of defendants to sufficient interpreters, added court staff and bringing in more prosecutors.

In addition, the added daily prisoners will clog or possibly overflow the Tucson courthouse's holding facilities, which accommodate only 80 prisoners now. They will require additional marshals for courtroom and cellblock operations and will rapidly fill vacant beds in federal detention centers in Arizona and other states, fueling added prisoner transportation and housing costs.

Then there's the cost of defense counsel.

Heather Williams, first assistant federal public defender in Tucson, said her office will provide two trial lawyers daily, each to represent six illegal immigrant defendants. Attorneys for the other 28 defendants will be appointed from a court-approved private attorney list at a congressionally approved cost of $100 an hour.

The program will cost about $2,600 a day from her office's budget. Court costs for the other defense attorneys will total another $7,200 to $8,000 daily, she said. If cases are heard 50 weeks a year, defense costs will approach $2.5 million a year.

And of the increased prison space:

Most federal prisoners processed through the federal court in Tucson are held at a Corrections Corporation of America facility in Florence, which receives about $10 million a month now, Gonzales said. Were there to be an additional hundred prisoners a day, the cost for bed space alone could double, he said. He said handling 100 new prisoners now would be beyond reach.

Williams says the program won't have a long-term deterrent effect:

In addition, she said, "From the start, the federal public defender has thought that this was ill-advised, that it may be depriving the defendants of effective assistance of counsel, including our finding people who may be citizens and who should not be in the room at all."

< Britain Considers Under-Skin Microchips for Prisoners | What's the Best Immigration Policy? >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    squeak (1.00 / 0) (#7)
    by jimakaPPJ on Sun Jan 13, 2008 at 03:27:55 PM EST
    What's more, according to Pew, of the total Hispanic immigrants working in construction last year, nearly two-thirds were "unauthorized.'' Labor specialists argue that these "unauthorized'' -- undocumented or illegal -- immigrants are the very ones willing to work for less than prevailing wages and worse than average conditions, particularly if they are not asked for documentation.

    So you believe that with almost 66% of the workers being illegal, legal US workers weren't losing jobs??

    hehe

    Your Poor (1.00 / 0) (#8)
    by squeaky on Sun Jan 13, 2008 at 04:47:46 PM EST
    Attempt to spin with GOP fearmongering tactics are transparent. The answer to your quote is available to anyone who wants to read the Pew Hispanic  Study. (PDF)

    Parent
    hehe (1.00 / 0) (#9)
    by jimakaPPJ on Sun Jan 13, 2008 at 07:37:59 PM EST
    The answer to your quote is available to anyone who wants to read the Pew Hispanic  Study. (PDF)

    Uh Squeak, did the fact that it was the Pew Report that I was quoting elude you? Really, squeak, try to focus.

    I repeat.

    What's more, according to Pew, of the total Hispanic immigrants working in construction last year, nearly two-thirds were "unauthorized.'' Labor specialists argue that these "unauthorized'' -- undocumented or illegal -- immigrants are the very ones willing to work for less than prevailing wages and worse than average conditions, particularly if they are not asked for documentation.

    So we have 66% illegal aliens and they haven't taken jobs from LEGAL US WORKERS? Who did they take them from, aliens from outer space?

    And did you miss this?

    Labor specialists argue that these "unauthorized'' -- undocumented or illegal -- immigrants are the very ones willing to work for less than prevailing wages and worse than average conditions, particularly if they are not asked for documentation.

    Do you even care about this?  I ask again. Have you every had a non-government job where actual labor was involved??

    Parent

    Baseless ppj BS (none / 0) (#11)
    by squeaky on Tue Jan 15, 2008 at 12:35:41 PM EST
    It is absurd that you continue to repeat your baseless conclusion regarding undocumented workers while implying that the Pew Report supports your insanity.

    The Pew study concludes after an exhaustive study that there is no correlation between unemployed native US workers and undocumented workers.

    You can repeat your dishonesty till you are blue in the face, but it still will not change the facts.  

    Parent

    Maybe they can cut (none / 0) (#1)
    by Jgarza on Sun Jan 13, 2008 at 12:19:45 AM EST
    costs by getting rid of Sheriff Arpaio.

    nah, put him in charge, (none / 0) (#2)
    by cpinva on Sun Jan 13, 2008 at 04:11:39 AM EST
    the "barbie pink" industry needs all the help it can get! lol

    you never know, with all those people being processed through, he might even end up "disappeared".

    Parent

    So much for Napolitano as VP (none / 0) (#3)
    by koshembos on Sun Jan 13, 2008 at 05:37:29 AM EST


    Oh Well (none / 0) (#4)
    by squeaky on Sun Jan 13, 2008 at 12:15:46 PM EST
    Maybe they can use the money that they make from undocumented workers. That would be an evil twist.

    Using an economic simulation model, the study's researchers tallied the fiscal costs and benefits of immigrants in Arizona's economy for 2004, finding that the total state tax revenue attributable to immigrant workers was nearly $2.4 billion ($860 million for naturalized citizens plus $1.5 billion for non-citizens, a majority of whom are likely undocumented) balanced against estimated fiscal costs of about $1.4 billion for a net positive impact of about $940 million.

    Although they would be ultimately shooting themselves in the foot:

    Gans said that non-citizen immigrants are a vital source of labor in key industries that employ large numbers of low-skilled workers such as construction, agriculture, manufacturing and various service industries. Eliminating these workers, she said, would result in lost output of approximately $29 billion.

    link


    hehe (1.00 / 0) (#5)
    by jimakaPPJ on Sun Jan 13, 2008 at 01:38:10 PM EST
    I see that you are hucking the Udall Report again.

    plus $1.5 billion for non-citizens, a majority of whom are likely undocumented)

    The fact is, of course, as shown by the Pew report you recently tried to misrepresent, is that these illegals took jobs that would have otherwise been taken by LEGAL US workers. So there is no net gain, just fiction propagated by proponents of the Open Borders.

    Parent

    I'm from Arizona (none / 0) (#10)
    by katmandu on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 12:32:34 AM EST
    Since illegal immigration already costs us
    over a billion a year, most of us are pleased
    that the gov't is doing something.
    Of course, we had to bring alot of the change
    about through the ballot system.
    Now, illegals cannot get gov't benefits,
    in state tuition, and companies that hire them
    knowingly will be fined then loose their
    licenses.
    We can't afford the costs of illegal aliens in
    Arizona.  
    Our governor tried to bill the feds a few
    billion for our costs--but they ignored the bill.
    I find it interesting that so many support the
    illegal aliens--as long as THEY don't have to
    pay the bill.
    Oh, by the way....
    Hurray for Sheriff Joe!!